top of page


David Cowles

Jul 15, 2024

“God places his words in Jeremiah’s mouth. How can this be consistent with Jeremiah’s status as a free and independent entity?”

“Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, before you were born, I dedicated you, a prophet to the nations I appointed you… See, I place my words in your mouth. Today I appoint you over nations and over kingdoms: to uproot and to tear down, to destroy and to demolish, to build and to plant.” (Jer 1:1 -10)

“Before I formed you…I knew you.” Phrases like this have often been mistakenly understood to mean that God has a grand plan for the world. Like a General Contractor, he knows exactly what he is going to do…and he does it. We merely follow his orders and, often unknowingly, even unwillingly, we help realize his designs. 

If that were true, an omnipotent God would have no use for use for us! His will would proceed from conception to execution instantaneously. We would be superfluous. But what a poor god this would be. I am reminded of Richie Rich, playing with his fancy toys, alone in his room.

But that is not what’s happening in Jeremiah, is it? God’s words are addressed to Jeremiah. He speaks to his prophet in the second person (du). He does not talk about Jeremiah the way some Frankenstein might talk about his monster. He does not order Jeremiah about like Alexa. 

God addresses Jeremiah as a true “Other” (Jean Paul Sartre), a “Thou” (Martin Buber). To recognize Jeremiah in this way is to recognize him as a free being, a co-creator, not a tool. (Unless we have ‘issues’, most of us do not make a habit of talking to our tools.)

Yet God knew Jeremiah before he formed him and dedicated Jeremiah before he was even born. Further, God places his words in Jeremiah’s mouth. How can this be consistent with Jeremiah’s status as a free and independent entity?

One key to unraveling this paradox lies in understanding Jeremiah’s mission: To uproot, to tear down, to destroy, to demolish, to build, to plant. God did not appoint Jeremiah to erect the Kingdom of God on Earth; that’s God’s job. Jeremiah is not God’s subcontractor, surely not his architect. That’s not how it works!

Jeremiah is not God’s craftsman; rather he is God’s “change agent”. He is the one who raises the old structures and levels the ground to make way for the new: God’s wrecking crew. Jeremiah tears down what is so that God can build a New Jerusalem on the spot.

Jeremiah does not impress God’s image upon the world’s clay. Rather he tears down the world’s icons and melts them back into raw material so that the evolutionary/historical process, God’s praxis, can do its work.

God knows the world’s origin: Logos (Gospel of John), the Word of God (God’s values). God’s Word (capital W) is reflected in the words (small w) that Jeremiah speaks. Jeremiah proclaims God’s values. Without God’s Word, God’s values, Jeremiah would have nothing to proclaim. God being God is what makes it possible for Jeremiah to be Jeremiah…and, BTW, for you to be you.

A similar ontological map can be found in the New Testament Letter to Ephesians (2:10): “For we are…created in Christ Jesus for the good works that God has prepared in advance, that we should live in them.”

The works are “prepared in advance”; they are the logical and practical consequence of God’s immutable values. But they do not ‘come to life’ until we animate them. It is up to us to step into those works so that we might “live in them”. 

God knows the world’s origin; God also knows the world’s destiny. Knowing that destiny, he knows everything and everyone who contribute to it…including Jeremiah. 

But knowing is not controlling. God’s knowledge (Parmenides’ Aletheia) is outside of time; it is the spaceless-timeless foundation through which the space-time universe (Parmenides’ Doxa) comes to be, on which that universe rests, into which it ultimately resolves itself. 

God’s eternal knowledge in no way compromises the radical freedom of the events that occur in our space-time universe. In the non-temporal sense (and only in that sense), we may say that God’s gnosis “precedes” (logically rather than temporally) his praxis (the world): He thinks before we act

That is the sense in which God knew Jeremiah before he was formed and dedicated him before he was born. The function of the free and independent Other in the space-time universe is to broadcast God’s Word and to remove impediments to the realization of God’s Kingdom in history (“Thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven”). 

Whether the Other accepts that function and performs it, and how the Other performs it, are matters entirely outside God’s control. The only thing certain is that someone (or ones) will ultimately step up. Why shouldn’t that someone be you?

The praxis that draws the world toward its destiny is ultimately from God, but it calls for others to project (speak) God’s vision (words) and to remove the world’s barriers (sin). The world’s destiny (God) is a lure, not an engraver’s plate. It works like a vacuum, created by what will ultimately be but is not yet and by the selective negation of what  already is. As such, God’s praxis draws the process we call “World” gently, unevenly, often imperceptibly, always unpredictably, but inevitably and inexorably toward its destiny.

In the New Testament we encounter John the Baptist, in many ways a later day version of Jeremiah. It is clear from the texts that God also knew John before he was formed and dedicated him before he was born. God also put his words on John’s tongue. John’s mission: “Prepare the way of the Lord, make straight his paths.” (Mt. 3:3)

In fact, the world is in perpetual need of Jeremiahs (and Johns). Like the Tower of Babel, the world’s hardened structures need to be uprooted so that the praxis of God can replace and perfect them. Our Jeremiahs are indeed “appointed over nations and kingdoms” because such social structures must always give way so that something greater and better can take their place: The Kingdom of God. 

Sin then, is another name for ‘institutional inertia’. Every earthly kingdom must someday be laid low so that the Kingdom of God may be all in all. In this context, we may recognize in Jeremiah the world’s first genuine “anarchist”; and in Jeremiah we may be encountering one of the first treatises on the philosophy of anarchism. Is Jeremiah a ‘first edition’ of The Anarchist’s Cookbook?

Jeremiah rests on the certain belief that the world is inevitably evolving in a positive direction and that our primary job as political actors is to tear down those anti-social social structures that prevent the world from following its natural course, its Tao.

Grace is flowing like a river…steadily, at all times. But the world’s vested interests have led to the erection of barriers, damns, that seek to restrict or, worse, redirect that flow. Prophets (like Jeremiah) are the icebreakers that clear the jam and allow the flow to resume its natural course.

However much we may deny and resist it, we are all in our own ways prophets. Intentionally or not, we all uproot the old and plant the new…which God will ultimately harvest. Therefore, we are all known by God before we are formed, and we are all dedicated before we are born.

We are not God’s tools, nor his robots, nor even his employees. Individually and collectively, we are that Other into whose eyes God perpetually stares. As the true ontological Other, we are by nature iconoclasts and as iconoclasts we participate in the ultimate realization of God’s praxis…however much we may “know not what we do”.


David Cowles is the founder and editor-in-chief of Aletheia Today Magazine. He lives with his family in Massachusetts where he studies and writes about philosophy, science, theology, and scripture. He can be reached at

purpose and devotion.


Return to our 2024 Beach Read

Have a comment about this ATM essay Join the conversation, and share your thoughts today..

Do you like what you just read? Subscribe today and receive sneak previews of Aletheia Today Magazine articles before they're published. Plus, you'll receive our quick-read, biweekly blog,  Thoughts While Shaving.

Thanks for subscribing!

bottom of page