The Structure of Consciousness

David Cowles
Nov 5, 2026
“Consciousness can be easily and simply modeled using just the lowly triangle…”
1600 words, 7 minute read
In the simplest possible terms, what do we mean when we say that someone, or something, is conscious? It is generally agreed that merely reacting to sensory input originating in an ‘external world’ is not enough.
According to Newton, every action entails an equal and opposite reaction, but we don’t necessarily view every action as conscious. A rock reacts to the force of gravity, but it may not be conscious. It ‘feels’ the tug but it is probably not aware that it feels the tug or even that there is a tug per se. A rock is not Descartes after all… is it?
Likewise, when we dream, we process sensory input, but we are not always conscious of the sensations we’re processing. And the last time you were in a coma, you heard everything I said to you and now you even remember some of it, but you weren’t conscious of it, or of yourself, at the time.
Most often, however, when we are aware of a sensation, we are also aware of ‘ourselves being aware’ of that sensation. We’re not just cold, we also know that we’re cold. There is a difference between being cold and thinking, “I’m cold.”
Ice is cold but there is no reason to think that it feels itself being cold or that it’s aware of its being cold. It’s just cold! Cold is what ice is; cold is part of its identity. It cannot not be cold and still be ice (as God cannot not be Good and still be God).
On the other hand, when I’m cold, I’m aware that I’m cold, and I’m aware that I’m aware that I’m cold. (As we say at the senior center, “I complain, therefore I am.”) I can aspire to be less cold without putting my identity at risk. In that Christmas film classic, Frosty the Snowman, when our hero warms up he disappears; when he refreezes, he is born again, de novo. Not so for me!
While any ‘it’ I experience is always only and ever it, there is an infinitesimal difference between my direct sensory experience of it and the indirect conceptual experience of it that I have whenever I’m aware of myself being aware of it.
Why is it that dreams seem so different from experiences? As above, when I’m cold IRL, I’m aware that I’m cold, and I’m aware that I’m aware that I’m cold. When I dream that I am cold, I am not necessarily cold IRL; I am just aware of coldness. My conceptual awareness is divorced from any physical sensation.
Similarly, Alfred North Whitehead distinguished our direct conceptual prehension of an ‘eternal object’ (value), e.g. coldness, from our physical prehension of that same value in another actual entity, e.g. an icywind, and from our conceptual apprehension of that physical sensation: to wit, “I am cold!”
That difference, what Jacques Derrida called la differance, is a precursor of all conscious experience, be it human…or other: dolphin or bonobo, octopus or parrot, AI or ET.
I experience the same input, but via two different media of transmission: (1) directly via my senses and (2) indirectly via my awareness of myself experiencing those sensations. And, per Marshall McLuhan, “the medium (of transmission) is the message,” and the message is la differance, ‘I am’, consciousness.
La differance may be understood as a quantum of difference, a bit of information, or a kernel of consciousness. It is irreducible. The ‘cold’ that I experience directly and the ‘cold’ that I experience through my being aware that I am cold are both the same and different.
Whenever A = -A (same = different) we know we’re not in Archimedes’ Kansas (aka the Set of Real Numbers) anymore. It is the same ‘cold’ but the different medium of transmission means that my experiences of that same cold differ slightly. La differance is short for ‘infinitesimal difference’.
Marcel Proust shares a similar insight in his Remembrance of Things Past (RTP):
“The sensation which I had once experienced as I stood upon two uneven stones in the Baptistry of St. Mark’s had, recurring a moment ago, been restored to me, complete with all the other sensations linked on that day to that particular sensation…
“…the past was made to encroach upon the present, and I was made to doubt whether I was in the one or the other… The moment to which I was transported seemed to me to be the present moment…” And so it was!
Proust was once the Proust of Italy and then the Proust of France but the Proust you know from RTP is the Proust of now, the Proust of both Italy and France. Every ‘then and there’ is here and now. An eventencapsulates time and so every event per se is atemporal (or eternal).
Proust does not remember Italy, he relives Italy, which is perhaps to say, he really lives it for the first time…but in France. Huh? When Proust was in Italy, his attention was divided between his experiences of Venice and his experience of himself experiencing Venice. But when Proust relives Italy in France, his intermediary physical body disappears (as it does in a dream) and now, for the first time, he fully experiences Venice as it is.
It is often said that the chief drawback of travel is having yourself as a travelling companion. Proust finds a way to skip out on that unwanted fellow traveler.
When Proust relives an event, he does not recall selected, superficial qualia associated with that event, like a tourist with a camera; he recreates the event entire, and like an Ephesian Kierkegaard, he leaps into it, re-experiencing all its qualia at once…not from outside-in, as perception and/or memory, but from inside-out, as something unknown to Kant, noumenal experience.
The phenomenon of differance enters into Proust’s experience twice, once as the infinitesimal unevenness of tiles, again as the infinitesimal separation between France-now and Italy-then. Separated in spacetime, the two venues are reunited by something even more substructural, i.e. experience.
Effectively, consciousness effects and reflects a ‘fold’ in spacetime that invalidates the familiar Euclidean metric. A tiny difference in the pitch of the tiles, the tinier the better, ideally the tiniest perceptible difference possible, becomes a worm hole for Proust, bending spacetime to bring together points otherwise distant from one another.
I am reminded of p-adic numbers: the closer they are to zero, the larger the quantity they represent. We travel furthest through the narrowest worm holes. I am also reminded of Bell’s non-locality (entanglement): two events indefinitely separated in space and time can nonetheless behave as one event.
Is this a manifestation of non-Archimedean structure in the real world? Check it out: If A is the combined experience of France-now and Italy-then, and B is the experience of ‘France-now’, and C is the experience of ‘Italy-then’, then both B and C are subsets of A but, counter intuitively, (B + C), France-and-Italy-now-and-then, has more value/weight/intensity for Proust than A itself.
Or, for you fans of Doctor Who, the Universe is simply a collection of ‘phone boxes’…tiny phone booths that house vast, hexagonal interior spaces, like the TARDIS. Either way, this potentiality for intensityis a product of living in a non-Archimedean universe and being conscious. Revel in it!
The competing cosmology is summarized by T.S. Eliot in Ash Wednesday: “Because I know that time is always time, and place is always and only place, and what is actual is actual only for one time, and only for one place, I rejoice that things are as they are and I renounce the blessed face…”
I’d rather live in Proust’s world than Eliot’s; how about you? Fortunately, we do; and for that may I say, “Thank God!” For Proust, space and time are folded so that any two points may be arbitrarily close to one another. Events, no matter how far apart, may abut.
While Proust’s epiphanies are dramatic, we all experience something similar most every waking moment of every day. Consciousness is the superposition of two images, slightly askew - differance as described above.
Surprisingly, the reputedly esoteric experience of consciousness can be easily and simply modeled using just the lowly triangle, the fundamental building block of the material world according to Plato (The Timaeus), Buckminster Fuller, et al. Consciousness can be modeled simply by treating the ordinarily static triangle as a dynamic process:
X
↙ ↘
Y → Z
In this diagram, X is directly aware of Z and of itself being aware (Y) of Z. We could say that ‘X’s experience of Z’ proceeds from X’s awareness of Z and from X’s awareness of being aware of Z (Y). In which case we would be characterizing ‘consciousness’ using the language adopted by the Council of Nicaea (c. 325 CE) to describe ‘God’, i.e. Trinity. Does that mean that you are God? Far from it! But it does mean that you, and perhaps every conscious being, is ‘made in the image and likeness of God’…and that’s not half bad.
Image: "Mauritshuis, The Hague."
Do you like what you just read and want to read more Thoughts? Subscribe today for free!
- the official blog of Aletheia Today Magazine.



