top of page

Markov Masks

David Cowles

Oct 27, 2026

“I am not who I think I am, I am not who you think I am; I am who I think you think I am.”

1150 words, 5 minute read


“And this is good old Boston, the home of the bean and the cod, where the Lowells talk only to Cabots and the Cabots talk only to God.” - John Collins Bossidy (c. 1910)


Who would have thought that this bit of ancient doggerel would prove to be an important anthropological model for the 21st century? We didn’t…but we probably should have. Art often presages developments in science and philosophy. Didn’t Picasso (Cubism) pave the way for Einstein (Relativity)? Didn’t the introduction of perspective in Renaissance painting pave the way for Machiavelli (Consequentialism) and the so-called Enlightenment (Utilitarianism)?


‘Boston 1910’ (above) models a concept (Markov Blanket) that was not discovered and named until 1988 (Judea Pearl); but as it turns out, the Cabots are its paradigm!


The poor Lowells – should they wish to consult the Deity, they can only do so through the Cabots. Like a now largely abandoned model of Church, the Cabots intercede (or not) on behalf of the Lowells and then “justify the ways of God to man,” i.e. to the Lowells. (Milton)


Likewise, should God have a message for a Lowell, Boston social etiquette requires he filter it through a Cabot. As presented, this arrangement is a bit of a nuisance and it does compromise the Lowells’ privacy, but in fact the ramifications are far more serious.


The Cabots are under no enforceable obligation to pass on the Lowells’ messages intact, or for that matter, to relay God’s responses. They are free to remain mute or, worse, to distort the God-Lowell messaging any way they wish. The power of the Cabots is awesome, much more so than Bossidy probably imagined.


And it’s not only Brahman Boston that channels interpersonal communication down a narrow necked funnel; it’s all of Western civilization. T.S. Eliot generalized  the concept somewhat more memorably:


“And indeed there will be time…time to prepare a face to meet the faces that you meet.” (The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock)

 

The human face is the ‘Universal Cabot’; it buffers every interpersonal communication. There is much talk today about Intersubjectivity. The idea goes back to Anaximander, the grandfather of Western philosophy (6th century BCE) but it is top of mind in the 20th century philosophies of Martin Buber, Alfred North Whitehead, and Jean-Paul Sartre.


Briefly, we become ourselves in the context of the other. We are because they are; we are who we are because of who they are. We imagine that we confront each other directly: “Look me in the eye and say that!” We neglect the fact that our faces, including and perhaps especially the eyes, act as intermediaries, i.e. masks…not windows!


Ignoring any question of duplicity, we will assume that I intend to communicate the contents of my mind to you and that I welcome you to share the contents of your mind with me. We habitually ignore the intermediary role played by our faces.


My face is the sort of two way mirror you’re familiar with since your last arrest. Like Narcissus, I project my image onto the interior surface of my face, and I see that image reflected back at me. So handsome! A bit long in the tooth perhaps…but so far so good.


Now I expect the exterior surface of my face to project that same image on to you. Here’s where we run into trouble. I want to share with you the deepest recesses of my soul. But that’s not what happens. My face never, or almost never, communicates my image as I intend. It has agency of its own. It reframes my messages before it communicates them…if it communicates them at all.


I have no control over how my face presents me. I can only try to influence it by what I project onto it. I can do no more than propose. Likewise, I can’t read the messages you would like to send me because your face is also a two way mirror. I can’t see past it into ‘your soul’.


So I have no idea what’s being communicated in my name…or do I? I can’t see my face…but I can see yours. But I only see what your face shows me.


Now the good part: I see your face reacting to my message and I imagine that I can read that reaction for clues to what message my face is communicating. I hope to discover the message I’m sending by reading your reaction from your face. I hope to learn how your image of me differs from my image of myself, i.e. from the message I wished to communicate to you.


I intended to present you with a beatific vision; but from your reaction, I surmise that it was more like a scene from Psycho. But then, of course, your face is also alienated from your intention; I can’t depend on your face to communicate faithfully your reaction. So, “what we have here is a failure to communicate.” (Cool Hand Luke) A massive failure! No wonder the world is at war.


1850 years before Eliot, St. Paul expressed a similar insight: “I do not do the good I intend, but the evil I do not intend, that I do.” (Romans 7: 19) Paul already understood the alienation that separates the manifestation from the intention. Paul’s entire physical self is a Markov Blanket (above), as is yours.


Charles Horton Cooley (c. 1920) summed the situation up: “I am not who I think I am, I am not who you think I am; I am who I think you think I am.”


Our faces are masks, Markov Masks. They are semi-permeable. I can see your mask through mine as you can see mine through yours, but I cannot see you as you see yourself or as you’d like me to see you; nor can you see me.


The concept of a Markov Mask seems weird. But it shouldn’t. IRL all interpersonal communication takes place through a medium and, per Marshall McLuhan and Jacques Derrida, the medium always distorts the intended message, so much so that we may sometimes say, “The medium is the message.” Perhaps there are no Lowells, or gods, but only Cabots.


Communication is a game (Wittgenstein), the game of life. Like Monopoly, it’s a game we play through avatars; but instead of hats and boots, our avatars are our faces…and now, our bots as well. Our bots are our next gen alter-egos. But the technology is nothing new. It dates back millennia. Evolution’s first agentic bot is the human face…and the human face is a Markov Mask.

 

Do you like what you just read and want to read more Thoughts? Subscribe today for free!

- the official blog of Aletheia Today Magazine. 

Have a thought to share about today's 'Thought'.png
bottom of page